中文 | ENG

第58卷 第3期 2025-5
Elevating the standards of scientific editing in clinical surgery: Learning from editorial and journal role models

.........................

第58卷 第3期 2025-5
Improving online physician evaluations for surgeons using sentiment analysis and alternative perspectives

.........................

第58卷 第3期 2025-5
Ensuring ethical and qualified authorship: The key to trustworthiness in clinical surgery journal

.........................

第58卷 第3期 2025-5
Artificial intelligence for academic purpose in clinic surgery: ChatGPT, Turnitin, and false positive

.........................

第58卷 第3期 2025-5
COVID-19, COVID-19 vaccination, risk of cardiac myxoma in view of clinical surgery

.........................

第58卷 第3期 2025-5
Eggplant deformity in penile fracture

.........................

第58卷 第3期 2025-5
Splenectomy for Klippel-Trenaunay syndrome: Systematic review and case series

.........................

第58卷 第3期 2025-5
Comments on “Risk factors for spinal cord injury without radiographic abnormality in trauma cases at a single trauma center”

.........................

第58卷 第3期 2025-5
Impact of fluorescence-guided surgery on splenic preservation: A case of splenic hydatidosis

.........................

第58卷 第3期 2025-5
Adult pancreatoblastoma presentingwith obstructive jaundice: A case report and literature review

.........................

第58卷 第3期 2025-5
Pilonidal disease management in young adults: A retrospective analysis of practices in a single tertiary center in Bahrain

.........................

第58卷 第3期 2025-5
Long-term comparative outcomes in patients undergoing transcatheter aortic valve implantation with self-expanding valves versus balloon-expandable valves: A retrospective observational study

.........................

第58卷 第3期 2025-5
Comparative study between the effectiveness of Amnion-CollaGee (Collagen-Gelatin-Elastin) as a biological product wound dressing and conventional dressing on the donor site of the split-thickness skin graft in animals model (rats)

.........................

第58卷 第3期 2025-5
Enhancing mortality Probability Model II predictive accuracy with the lethal triad in intensive care unit trauma patients: A retrospective study

.........................

第58卷 第3期 2025-5
Dr. Shao-Wei Chen's contribution to analysis of outcomes of patients undergoing cardiac surgery and aortic disease: Big data analytics

.........................

第58卷 第2期 2025-3
Predatory publisher and low standard journal: An emerging problem in clinical surgery field

.........................

第58卷 第2期 2025-3
Conflict of interest in clinical surgery: Contemporary concern in digital era

.........................

第58卷 第2期 2025-3
Postpublication redecision and pitfalls of inadequate standards in scientific surgical journals: Important consideration in academic publication

.........................

第58卷 第2期 2025-3
Spontaneous bilateral basal ganglia hemorrhage

.........................

第58卷 第2期 2025-3
Academic characterization of the Formosan Journal of Surgery: A five-year bibliometric analysis

.........................
登入帳號才能閱讀全文
 
篇名 Factors influencing the outcome of necrotizing fasciitis
作者 Fachreza Aryo Damara, Dedy Pratama
卷期/出版年月 54卷5期 (2021/10)
頁次 203-203
摘要 Dear Editor, We have read with great interest an original article entitled, “Predictors of mortality in necrotizing fasciitis” by Kumar and Lal in a recent issue at Formosan Journal of Surgery (2021; 54: 52–60).[1] We would like to congratulate the authors for their incredible work and contributions. Necrotizing fasciitis (NF) is a diagnosis involving skin and soft tissue infections that commonly requires immediate definitive surgical intervention.[2,3] As a consequence, recognizing risk factors that may attribute to poor outcomes in an early encounter is important to acknowledge physicians to understand the disease progressivity. Several prior studies have been conducted to extensively analyze early signs that can be obtained from history‑taking, physical examination, and laboratory results. Apart from the importance of this study – providing the study results from another study setting’s perspective, there are other components of predictors that should be further discussed in this study. The authors discussed several physical and laboratory examination findings and their influence on mortality rate. However, the study findings did not include hemorrhagic bullae in its analysis. The presence of bullae differentiates NF from other skin and soft tissue infections.[4] A previous meta‑analysis involving 23 studies indicates that hemorrhagic bullae was associated with NF with a sensitivity of 25.2% (95% confidence interval [CI] 12.8%–43.7%) and specificity of 95.8% (95% CI 87.3%–98.7%).[2] Therefore, that the presence of hemorrhagic bullae should be included in the analysis to understand whether it influences NF mortality in the study. In addition, choosing the effect measure in the study is essential to provide clinicians with an accurate statistical interpretation that will be translated into the clinical practice. As this study provides important findings to take the results into account in better predicting patient mortality, presenting the value of sensitivity and specificity of several most influencing factors is needed. Further, although the authors have stated the P value of univariate and multivariate regression analyses, the value of odd ratio as an effect measure ought to be included to provide another value for researchers who are conducting a secondary study to investigate these factors.
關鍵詞
分類 Letter to the Editor

台灣外科醫學會雜誌 © 2006 Taiwan Surgical Association All Rights Reserved
會 址:台北市南京東路五段 31 號 3 樓
電 話:(02) 2769-7845 傳 真:(02) 2746-7149 Email: journal@surgery.org.tw